Law and Ethics Practice Exam

What is a key reason for holding a minor under a 5585 hold?

1. Inability to attend school regularly

2. Severe emotional distress affecting well-being

3. Grave disability or risk of harm to self/others

4. A parent’s request for psychological assessment

The correct answer is: Grave disability or risk of harm to self/others

Holding a minor under a 5585 hold primarily centers around the concept of grave disability or the risk of harm to themselves or others. This legal provision allows for the temporary detention of a minor when they are deemed to be a danger to themselves or others, or if they cannot provide for their basic needs due to mental health issues. The rationale behind this provision is to ensure the safety and well-being of the minor, as well as the safety of the community. When a minor exhibits behaviors or conditions that indicate they may harm themselves or face significant risks, such as suicidal tendencies or aggressive behavior towards others, a 5585 hold is necessary to facilitate immediate intervention and appropriate mental health treatment. In this context, while the other options may represent important considerations in the broader discussion of a minor's well-being, they do not address the immediate and critical need for intervention associated with the potential for serious harm. For instance, difficulties in attending school or requesting an assessment do not justify a hold on their own without a direct implication of immediate harm or severe incapacity. Severe emotional distress, while significant, must also be linked to a specific risk or inability to function effectively, which aligns more closely with the criteria set forth under the 5585 hold.